Roof Replacement Vs. Repair: Making the Best Decision

roof replacement

If your Cincinnati roof is damaged from old age or storms, you have two choices for maintenance: repair or replacement. Figuring out which one is best will depend on the age of the roof, the types of damage that are present, and other factors. Here are some tips on how to select whether your roof needs a simple repair or an entire replacement from your contractor.

Repairing Your Roof

Roof repair targets specific areas that are in need of maintenance. This option is typically for minor and moderate damages as it is less invasive to the roof. Many homeowners can perform a self-inspection to look for signs of damage by using binoculars from the ground. For a more detailed inspection, you may contact a professional who can get onto the roof to get a closer look. They can catch hidden dangers that may require a more comprehensive solution.

Replacing Your Roof

Roof replacement is a more involved process that involves the entire roof. It is often performed when the damage is to the extent that repairs will not fix the issue. You may also replace the roof if it is nearing the end of the lifespan for the materials, if you want to change the design, or if you plan to sell the home. Typical roof replacement work focuses on the sheathing, rafters, and trusses.

When compared to roof repairs, roof replacement is more expensive initially. Yet your insurance may cover the costs depending on the type of damage and your policy. Before any replacement work begins, a professional should perform an inspection.


Re-roofing is a more uncommon method for fixing your home. It’s less labor intensive than the other methods as it doesn’t involve removing the existing materials. Instead, a new shingle overlay is installed over the current shingles. There are several reasons why this solution is not recommended.

Putting on another layer of shingles can cover up serious damage, as that damage can worsen from age, humidity, and heat. Also, it increases the weight on top of the roof and puts unnecessary stress on trusses and rafters.

Factors to Consider When Making the Decision

When deciding between roof replacement, consider the present age of the roof and the condition. There may be newer roofing products available that are stronger and more weather-resistant. Also, consider the size of the damaged area. If it is just a small area, then repairs may be more cost-effective.

You can also consider how long you will live there. If you plan to move soon, you may simply repair the damage and allow the next homeowner to replace the roof. Lastly, consider the price of the roof repairs vs replacement and whether you are eligible for reimbursement through an insurance claim. If the roof was damaged by weather or an accident, your insurance company may provide partial or full payment that can go toward fixing the roof.

Whether you are getting roof repair or replacement services, hiring professionals at Brandstetter’s KangaRoof ensures that the project will be completed to your specifications. Reach out to us today to get a quote.